A Letter Reflecting on the Methodist Decision

(Author note:  Jules is my 30-year old child who came out as lesbian at age 19 and trans androgynous at age 28. They/their/them are preferred pronouns. I share this with their permission.)

Dear Jules,

This may seem like an odd letter to come from your dad at this time. I have a feeling that I am writing as much as a confessional for me as I am out of care for you. My motivations are not exactly clear, yet I feel that I need to share this with you.

I don’t know if you have been following the news of the General Conference of the United Methodist Church these last few days. In fact, as I say this I sort of smile, as I am aware that following church news is not something that you have done for a long time nor even feel compelled to do. But I do want to catch you up on it and then explain to you why I am writing.

gay coupleOur Methodist friends were wrestling this past weekend with the same issues we Presbyterians were wrestling with over four years ago in 2014. You know the issue I am talking about—the issue of the inclusion of LGBTQ+ persons in the leadership of our churches and the support of same sex marriages. You might remember from our conversations that we Presbyterians voted to take our prohibitive language out of our Book of Order which made room for churches and their leaders to become more inclusive. Some churches took advantage of the new freedom, some decided to make no changes to their historic stances, and some were so troubled by the “relaxing of standards” that they left the denomination.

I have been in touch with Brandon over these last few weeks, you know my Methodist preacher friend, as he was watching and praying his way through this in his denomination. Of course, you know what he was hoping for—a decision to finally free up his churches to be more inclusive of the LGBTQ+ community. I know Brandon and many of his colleagues and friends were disappointed when the General Conference voted for what was called the Traditional Plan. The title itself doesn’t need much explanation except to say that things didn’t change much. If the LGBTQ+ community didn’t feel very welcome ten years ago they may feel even more unwelcome today.

Of course, a vote by an international body doesn’t mean every individual church feels this way. It just means that the majority felt that way and those who disagreed are now left with how to respond in a way that feels faithful to the gospel of Jesus Christ. I have many Methodist friends who are deeply hurt by this recent vote.

So why am I writing to you? I am writing to you because I feel some conflict between my role as your father and my role as a Presbytery leader who is responsible for the spiritual lives of 96 churches and 14,000 members. You know that if I was just acting as your father I would send a heartfelt, sad, and possibly angry letter to our Methodist friends and tell them that this is personal. This cuts at the very fabric of our family. But as a religious leader I have to be cognizant of the diversity of the people in the pews—some who are ready to march in protest against this decision as well as those who are breathing a sigh of relief and applaud this decision of the Methodist world communion.

I want to have something pastoral to say to our own denomination. I want to have something prophetic to say to the people of our presbytery. This is not a time to be silent, but I am torn, as you probably can guess.

You know that I have enough of a counselor’s heart to know that I believe that all growth starts with accepting people where they are, giving them information and then watching the spirit move their hearts and their lives at a pace that is true to how they are psychologically built. I learned long ago when I was a probation officer that I can’t make people change. I can only make sure they have all the information and tools they need, understand the consequences of their actions, and then walk with them as they make their own choices. In the end, if I did that I always felt good about my presence, even if I had hoped for a different outcome for them.

But it still pains me. It pains me that I am choosing to be patient with people while you are carrying pepper spray because of the recent attacks on queer people in Portland. Am I letting you down by not driving around to every church in our presbytery and insisting that enough is enough? Anything short of full inclusion of LGBTQ+ people in our presbytery will not be acceptable, is not a good reflection of Jesus’ life and not okay with this father. Or would I be letting our presbytery down if I came out too strongly on one side or another and delighted some of our churches and offended others splitting our presbytery into two distinct camps?

I cried big ol’ dad tears today when you told me that you have now learned to stay away from certain areas friendly to queers because they have become targets for attacks by the Proud Boys. I cried because within 24 hours of each other the Methodist Church majority just voted to say, “We are not going to make it feel any safer for your kind,” and you just told me that “queer hangouts” are not a safe place for you given the recent movement to target your kind. Is there any safe place for you, my dear one?

As a father this just kills me. As a father I want to march out of my house right now and make this right. As a father I want to toss out any calls for me to be tolerant and understanding. As a father I don’t want to hear that change takes time.

So why I am writing this letter? I think it is a confessional. It is a way to work through my conflicting feelings. It is a way to ask your forgiveness if I don’t take enough decisive action and to ask for my presbytery’s forgiveness if I take too much decisive action.

Jules, I know that I can’t promise you that I will make the church more inclusive and that it will ever feel safe enough for you to open your beautiful heart to them, to reveal your full-sleeved tattoos, and to share communion with them in a way that you know you are just as much a part of the body of Christ as anyone.

But I can promise you this. I will continue to love the people of my presbytery. I will continue to accept them for who they are now because that is who I am and how I work. I will continue to walk with them and work with them at a pace that they can handle.

But I will also tell them that this isn’t just about church polity. This isn’t just about political correctness. This is personal. This is Jesus stuff.

“Take your time,” I will say, “but know that every hour that you wait breaks a father’s heart.”

Keep your pepper spray handy, my lovely.

Love,

Dad

Rev. Brian Heron, Presbyter for Vision and Mission, Presbytery of the Cascades

7 thoughts on “A Letter Reflecting on the Methodist Decision

  1. Thank you for sharing. Our church’s inclusion and love for all people is what brought our family back to church. We will continue to raise our kids to love others the way Jesus loves us. Please tell Jules that they are an inspiration to children and adults. My son’s first best friend is trans and knew at 5 exactly who he was. I pray that everyone can be as brave as your child and our son’s friend to be true to themselves and know that God loves us. I also pray that as Christians we can continue to support and love each other as we journey together on a path of more acceptance and love.

    Like

  2. Inclusion can be a tricky concept in application. Does it include people who do not embrace inclusiveness themselves? Where is the line between inclusion of people who themselves exclude others, and collusion with their practices? I don’t pretend to have the answers myself, so I appreciated your honest sharing of the dilemma.

    I was impressed by a pastor’s response to a congregation member who asked him how to grow their church, which, like many churches, was becoming smaller and “grayer.”

    “Well,” he responded, “that depends on what you are willing to risk. Everyone who is like you is already here.”

    Like

    1. Galen, thank you for your thoughtful response. That is just the issue that I am wrestling with. What does it mean to love my trans child and be supportive of their journey and to love the people of my presbytery and be supportive of their journey. I don’t have easy answers either, just an honest admission that I wrestle with the question.
      And the “growing churches” vignette is perfect! “It depends on what you are willing to risk.” Perfect, perfect, perfect!

      Like

  3. Like you I have a loved one living in Portland for whom I fear; I wonder throughout each day if he is safe just making his way to work, during time with friends, at the gym or running and biking alone on his city’s streets. He has great support in his many communities within the city, but still I’m anxious for him.
    My anxiety does not get soothed or reassured within my own Presbyterian church. Oh, yes, the words for inclusion are there and many believe strongly in that inclusion and I feel their support for my child. However, each Sunday seated around me are those who profess their desire to love as Jesus loves, yet speak of “hating the sin, but loving the sinner” and those who continue to tightly hold on to those dreaded and hateful interpretations of scripture they believe prove their point. Change has been happening too fast for some and so slow for those of us who wait for for an honest inclusion that would make your Jules and my Jason feel safe, accepted, respected and affirmed.

    Like

    1. Bless you, Loreen, as you also personally wrestle with the question of how much change is too slow for you and your son and too fast for some in the church. I think just being honest about my struggle is about the best I can do.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s